Last updated: November 18, 2026· By Seckin Peker

Halloween Costume Idea For 1920s Party Lovers

Jay Gatsby From The Great Gatsby Halloween Costume

He hosts the biggest party in town and still keeps one eye on the door.
Couple/DuoFemaleLeonardo DiCaprioMale
🍸
Quick Answer: The Jay Gatsby Halloween costume is a black three-piece suit with a bow tie and a glass to toast with.
  • Black Three-Piece Suit (essential)
  • Margarita Glass (essential)
  • White Dress Shirt
  • White Handkerchief
  • Black Bow Tie
  • Black Dress Shoes

Jay Gatsby throws huge parties and spends them watching the door for one particular guest. The black suit and a glass raised in a toast are what people remember, from the 2013 film directed by Baz Luhrmann with Leonardo DiCaprio as Gatsby (Wikipedia). Nearly everyone knows the name, even people who skipped the book, so it needs no explaining.

Items Total6 Items
DifficultyEasy
VibeBlack-Tie Jazz Age Host
Cost$120-$190

Jay Gatsby Halloween Costume Items

Jay Gatsby from The Great Gatsby 2013 Halloween costume infographic showing a black three-piece suit, margarita glass, white dress shirt, white handkerchief, black bow tie, and black dress shoes

Jay Gatsby Costume Items

Affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Jay Gatsby The Great Gatsby 1920s Black Tie
  • 1 Black Three-Piece Suit (essential)Jacket, vest, and pants, all black. This is the party look from the 2013 film’s toast scene, and it is the one people picture. Gatsby wears cream and pink in other scenes, but black is what gets recognized. A slim cut gets tight across the shoulders when you raise an arm, so try it on and lift a glass before the party.
    See on Amazon
  • 2 Margarita Glass (essential)A wide, shallow glass raised toward the camera is the whole pose. It comes as a pack of 50, which is far more than one person needs, so split it with friends or leave a stack on the snack table. Plastic is the right call, because you will hold it for hours and drop it at least once.
    See on Amazon
  • 3 White Dress ShirtPlain white, no pattern. Check your closet first.
    See on Amazon
  • 4 White HandkerchiefFold it flat so a thin white edge shows above the jacket pocket. Skip it if you already own a pocket square.
    See on Amazon
  • 5 Black Bow TiePre-tied is fine, since nobody checks the knot. Make sure the band fits snug, because a loose one spins around your neck.
    See on Amazon
  • 6 Black Dress ShoesBlack lace-up oxfords. Check your closet first, and wear new pairs around the house before the party.
    See on Amazon
Jay Gatsby in a black suit dancing with Daisy Buchanan in profile, reference scene for the Great Gatsby Halloween costume

How to Style the Jay Gatsby Halloween Costume

Black jacket, white shirt, and bow tie is also what a waiter wears. The vest and a glass held up in front of you are what separate the two. People skip the vest first. Then someone asks where the bathrooms are.

Gatsby calls nearly everyone “old sport,” including people he met a minute ago. Say it to one guest at the party and keep a straight face. It lands once.

Fill the glass a third

A wide glass with a full drink spills the moment you raise it for a photo. Pour a little, or hold it empty for pictures and fill it after.

Test the bow tie band

A pre-tied bow tie with a loose band slides to one side by the second hour. Put it on at home and turn your head a few times before you leave.

Jay Gatsby Group Halloween Costume Ideas

Duo Idea

Jay Gatsby & Daisy Buchanan

Excellent duo idea, since his black suit and her pale beaded dress look like two different worlds with no explanation needed. Daisy is the harder build, with a dress, wig, and headband, so the work is not split evenly.

Jay Gatsby Daisy Buchanan

Group Idea: West Egg

Gatsby, Daisy, Nick Carraway & Tom Buchanan

Strong if all four of you commit. Nick and Tom wear plain 1920s suits, so without name tags or a pose they look like four guests at a vintage wedding.

Jay Gatsby Daisy Buchanan Nick Carraway Tom Buchanan
Three-panel collage of Jay Gatsby at his party with fireworks behind him, reference for the Halloween costume

Jay Gatsby Halloween Costume DIY Tips

Building the Look

Most of this may already be in your closet. The suit is the only piece worth buying new.

  • Suit: buy it, or borrow a black tux from a friend who owns one.
  • Shirt: plain white, whatever you have.
  • Handkerchief: a clean white cloth napkin folded small does the job.
  • Bow tie: buy it pre-tied unless you can tie one without a mirror.
  • Shoes: any black dress shoes, but polish them.

Playing Gatsby at the Party

He is warm, polite, and a little too eager. Do not overplay it.

  • Say “old sport” once or twice. Any more and it becomes your whole personality.
  • Raise the glass when someone takes your photo.
  • Stay near the entrance and glance at it now and then. He throws these parties hoping Daisy walks in.

Jay Gatsby Halloween Costume: FAQ

Wear a black three-piece suit with a white dress shirt, a black bow tie, and black dress shoes. Fold a white handkerchief into the pocket and carry a wide, shallow glass. Black matches the 2013 film’s party look, not the cream suits you see in some guides.

Yes, mostly because everyone knows the name and the film’s raised-glass image has not gone away. A stage musical version is also on tour in the US, which keeps the story in the news. The catch is that it is a common pick, so expect another black suit with a glass at any 1920s party.

He says “Can’t repeat the past? Why of course you can!” to Nick. He also says “Her voice is full of money,” about Daisy. And he calls almost everyone “old sport.” All three come from F. Scott Fitzgerald’s 1925 novel (Wikiquote).

No. In the novel he wears a white flannel suit with a silver shirt and a gold tie. The black tuxedo look is the film’s choice, and Catherine Martin won the Oscar for Best Costume Design for it (National Film and Sound Archive of Australia).

Yes. Cream or white follows the book, and pink matches a scene in the film. Black reads fastest at a party, so that is the one I built this around.

If you do not want to be mistaken for a waiter, yes. A black suit with a white shirt and bow tie is also a server’s uniform, and the vest is what separates the two.

No, but without it you are a man in a black suit. The raised glass is what tells people who you are, so hold it up when someone points a camera at you.

Who directed the 2013 Great Gatsby film?

What does Gatsby call almost everyone he meets?

Who won the Oscar for Best Costume Design for the 2013 film?

Leave a Comment