Nicholas Scratch Costume Guide

Nicholas Scratch, a charismatic warlock from the world of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, is a complex and intriguing character. This costume guide will help you recreate his signature look and embody his captivating spirit. We'll cover crafting his iconic outfit, adopting his mannerisms, and even explore ways to turn your Nicholas Scratch costume into a group affair. Through my years of preparing hundreds of costume guides, I'll provide insights and resources to ensure your Nicholas Scratch costume is both authentic and impressive.

  • Difficulty: 1/10  Creating a Nicholas Scratch costume presents a easy. The character's style is relatively straightforward.
  • Can you build it from your own wardrobe:  It depends on the individual's existing wardrobe. Those with a penchant for dark, tailored pieces might find they already own items that closely resemble Nicholas's style.
  • Scare factor: 1/10 - Nicholas Scratch's costume leans more towards the charismatic and enigmatic than outright scary. The character's allure comes from his mysterious persona rather than any horror elements, making the scare factor relatively low.
  • Cost: $$$$$ Here's a rough breakdown:
      • Basic (from your wardrobe or thrifted): ~$20-$40 If you're able to utilize pieces from your own wardrobe or find suitable items at a thrift store, the cost can be kept relatively low. Essential elements like a dress shirt and trousers are commonly available and inexpensive.
      • Mid-range (mix of new and pre-owned items): ~$50-$100 Purchasing new elements like a high-quality quilted jacket or leather shoes, possibly in combination with thrifted items, will increase the cost. Prices can vary widely based on the quality and source of the clothing.
      • High-End (replica pieces): ~$100+ For those aiming for an exact replica of Nicholas Scratch's outfit, especially custom-made or high-end versions of his quilted jacket and accessories, costs can escalate. This option is for enthusiasts who prioritize accuracy and quality in their costume.

 Nicholas Scratch Costume Essentials

How to DIY Nicholas Scratch's Iconic Look

Diving into the world of Nicholas Scratch from Chilling Adventures of Sabrina offers a unique blend of sophistication and edge. Emulating Nicholas's style means capturing his warlock essence while balancing modern elegance. We've previously outlined a shopping list for those ready to purchase Nicholas Scratch costume pieces directly. However, for those who revel in the creativity and personal touch of DIY, or looking for a more budget friendly approach, this section is your blueprint to fashioning Nicholas Scratch's signature look from scratch.

Quilted Jacket

What You Need:

  • Black fabric, preferably quilted for texture
  • Snap buttons for front closure
  • Black thread and sewing essentials
  • Pattern for a basic men's jacket

How to Do It:

  1. Use the jacket pattern to cut your quilted fabric according to Nicholas's jacket style.
  2. Sew the pieces together, focusing on creating a snug, comfortable fit.
  3. Attach snap buttons along the front closure for that distinct Nicholas Scratch look.
  4. Add pockets with flaps and snaps on the chest and sides for functionality and style.

Bonus Tips: For those less inclined to sew, a plain black quilted jacket can be modified with snap buttons added to the front. Customize it by sewing on additional pockets to mimic Nicholas's style closely.

Dress Shirt

What You Need:

  • Light blue fabric, soft and comfortable
  • Button-down shirt pattern
  • White buttons
  • Sewing kit

How to Do It:

  1. Following the shirt pattern, cut your fabric to shape.
  2. Assemble the pieces, paying close attention to the collar and cuffs for that sharp, classic look.
  3. Sew on the buttons, ensuring the front chest pocket is included for authenticity.

Bonus Tips: Thrift stores are gold mines for finding basic pieces like a light blue dress shirt. You can easily add a personal touch with custom buttons or slight alterations to fit the Nicholas Scratch vibe.

Leather Belt

What You Need:

  • Black leather or faux leather material
  • Silver-toned rectangular buckle
  • Leather hole puncher

How to Do It:

  1. Cut the leather material to your waist size plus extra for adjustment.
  2. Attach the buckle, securing it in place.
  3. Use the hole puncher to create belt holes for a custom fit.

Bonus Tips: A high-quality thrift store or craft store belt can serve as a base. Customize it by changing the buckle to a silver-toned rectangular one for an authentic Nicholas Scratch accessory.


What You Need:

  • Charcoal grey fabric, durable yet stylish
  • Pattern for men's trousers
  • Sewing essentials

How to Do It:

  1. Select a pattern that matches the straight-leg or slim-fit style of Nicholas's trousers.
  2. Cut and sew the fabric, ensuring a sleek and comfortable fit.
  3. Pay attention to detail, such as the hem and waistband, for a polished look.

Bonus Tips: Altering an existing pair of charcoal grey trousers may be more accessible for some. Adjust the fit as needed to match Nicholas's style closely, focusing on achieving a tailored, slim silhouette.


What You Need:

  • Black leather dress shoes
  • Shoe polish for added shine

How to Do It:

  1. This is one aspect where DIY might be more about sourcing than crafting. Look for a simple, elegant pair of black leather shoes that embody Nicholas's style.
  2. Use shoe polish to give them the slight shine that matches Nicholas's polished yet practical footwear choice.

Bonus Tips: Thrift shops and second-hand stores can be excellent places to find quality leather shoes without the hefty price tag. A bit of polish and care can transform them into the perfect Nicholas Scratch costume addition.

Creating the key pieces of Nicholas Scratch's outfit is where the magic of DIY truly shines. Next up, let's unlock the secrets to embodying his attitude!

Nicholas Scratch Cosplay

Transforming into Nicholas Scratch isn't just about the clothes; it's about embodying his effortlessly cool confidence. Let's dive into the subtle mannerisms that will truly make your Nicholas Scratch costume come alive!

How to act like Nicholas Scratch at the Halloween Party:

Casual Confidence

  • What To Do: Nicholas carries himself with a laid-back yet assured air. There's an underlying strength in his relaxed demeanor.
  • How To Do It:
    • Posture: Stand tall, shoulders back, but not rigidly so. Keep your chin slightly raised.
    • Movement: Move with a deliberate pace, not rushed or frantic. Imagine the calm precision of a skilled warlock.
    • Eye Contact: Maintain strong eye contact when interacting with others. This exudes confidence without being overtly aggressive.
  • Bonus Tips:
    • I think part of Nicholas's charm is his contrast between casual demeanor and intense focus when it matters. Channel this during conversations – be laid-back in your body language but fully present in the moment.
    • Practice this posture and movement in front of a mirror to master the vibe.

Subtle Smirk

  • What To Do: Nicholas frequently sports a subtle, slightly mischievous half-smirk. It conveys a sense of knowing amusement.
  • How To Do It:
    • Less is More: Start with a very slight upturn of only one corner of your mouth. It's more about the attitude than a full-fledged grin.
    • The Eyes Tell It: Pair this with a relaxed gaze and slightly raised eyebrow to complete the playful look.
    • Context is Key: Use this expression sparingly. It's most effective when reacting to something others say or do.
  • Bonus Tips:
    • Master this in a mirror! It can easily veer into looking cocky, so subtlety is key.
    • Imagine Nicholas's inner thoughts when deploying the smirk – what's amusing him in that moment?

Protective Instincts

  • What To Do: While often laid-back, Nicholas fiercely defends those he cares for, particularly Sabrina. This reveals a deeper layer to his personality.
  • How To Do It:
    • Body Language Shifts: When someone "threatens" Sabrina (verbally or otherwise), subtly change your posture. Stand a bit straighter, subtly move closer to her, and let your expression harden.
    • Verbal Cues: Speak with a firmer tone and directness; drop the casual playfulness. Don't be afraid to use blunt or challenging phrases if the situation calls for it.
    • Eyes Tell the Story: Your gaze should become focused and intense, conveying unwavering protectiveness.
  • Bonus Tips:
    • This aspect of Nicholas shows through most clearly in his interactions with Sabrina's antagonists. Study specific scenes to get a feel for the shift in his demeanor.
    • Remember, he's not an impulsive hothead. His protective side is still calculated and strategic.

Hints of Vulnerability

  • What To Do: Despite his confidence, Nicholas has moments of vulnerability, often tied to his feelings for Sabrina.
  • How To Do It:
    • Soften the Expression: Let your usual smirk fade. Allow a hint of uncertainty or longing to show in your eyes.
    • Subtle Gestures: A slight hesitation before speaking, a glance away, or a touch of his own chest (near the heart) can convey inner conflict.
    • Less is More: Overdoing it risks making him seem whiny. These moments should be brief and poignant.
  • Bonus Tips:
    • This is where my experience watching countless cosplay performances comes in handy – the tiny details are what sell a complex character!
    • Rewatch scenes where Nicholas struggles with his feelings or loyalty to the Dark Lord to perfect these subtle cues.

Mastering these traits will bring your Nicholas Scratch costume to life. Combine them with his iconic look, and your transformation will be complete!

Couple, Group and Family Costume Ideas 

Elevate your Nicholas Scratch costume to the next level with these engaging couple, group, and family costume ideas, drawing inspiration from the captivating universe of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina and beyond.

Couple Costume Ideas

Idea 1: Nicholas Scratch and Sabrina Spellman

Nicholas and Sabrina's relationship is central to the series, making them an ideal couple's costume. This pairing works because it captures the dynamic and sometimes tumultuous romance between the warlock and the witch. Dressing as Nicholas and Sabrina offers a mix of magical sophistication and teenage angst, perfect for any event. This one is my favorite couple costume idea for its depth and narrative significance.

Idea 2: Nicholas Scratch and Ambrose Spellman

As cousins and confidants within the magical realm, Nicholas and Ambrose present a thematic duo highlighting the camaraderie and complexities of their world. Their contrasting styles—Nicholas's dark, brooding look against Ambrose's more eclectic, bohemian vibe—create a visually appealing and iconic pair that celebrates the diversity of warlock fashion and personality.

Idea 3: Nicholas Scratch and Harvey Kinkle

For a cross-universe twist, pair Nicholas Scratch with Harvey Kinkle from Sabrina the Teenage Witch. Despite being from different adaptations, this duo bridges the worlds of the Archie Comics series, showcasing the enduring legacy of these characters. The contrast between Nicholas's dark warlock attire and Harvey's quintessential "boy next door" look offers a fun, creative challenge for couples looking to blend elements from both series.

Group Costume Ideas

Idea 1: The Academy of Unseen Arts

Gather your friends to embody the students and faculty of the Academy of Unseen Arts. Including characters like Nicholas, Sabrina, Prudence, and Ambrose, this group costume idea celebrates the rich tapestry of personalities within the series. It's an excellent opportunity for a larger group to showcase the variety of witch and warlock aesthetics from the show.

Idea 2: The Spellman Family and Friends

This theme allows for a mix of characters from the Spellman household and their closest allies. Combining Sabrina, Zelda, Hilda, Ambrose, and Nicholas, this group costume explores the intersection of family and magic. It's a chance to highlight the show's core themes of love, loyalty, and the pursuit of identity within the magical world.

Idea 3: Crossover Coven

Create a crossover ensemble with characters from different magical universes, such as Harry Potter, The Magicians, or Buffy the Vampire Slayer. This idea celebrates the universal appeal of magical stories, allowing each person to embody their favorite witch, warlock, or magical being. It's a fun way to explore similarities and differences in magical lore across popular culture.

Family Costume Ideas

Idea 1: The Church of Night

For a family looking to dive deep into the world of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, dressing as members of the Church of Night offers a range of characters, from the High Priest to the newest initiate. This idea allows for a broad interpretation of witch and warlock attire, accommodating various ages and preferences within the family.

Idea 2: Sabrina's Worlds Collide

This broader theme encompasses characters from both Sabrina's mortal and magical lives, allowing family members to choose from a wide array of roles ranging from high school friends to demonic adversaries. It's a fantastic way to cater to the diverse interests and ages within a family, all while staying connected to the show's universe.

Through years of creating and participating in group costumes, I've found that the key to a successful ensemble lies in coordination and a shared vision. Whether opting for a direct adaptation or a creative crossover, these ideas are designed to be inclusive and adaptable, ensuring everyone can partake in the fun. By sharing these insights and suggestions, I aim to inspire your next costume adventure, fostering creativity and collaboration among fans of all ages.

About Nicholas Scratch

Uncover the layers of Nicholas Scratch, a character whose complexities and charm resonate deeply within the Chilling Adventures of Sabrina. This exploration delves into what makes Nicholas not just a warlock, but a figure of intrigue and depth.

Character Overview

  • Role in the Narrative: Nicholas serves as a pivotal character within the series, positioned as Sabrina's ally, confidant, and romantic interest. His presence introduces themes of loyalty, sacrifice, and the challenging balance between darkness and light within the magical realm.
  • Played By: Gavin Leatherwood

Background and Personality Traits

  • Personality: Nicholas is characterized by his progressive ideas, charm, and a laid-back yet confident demeanor. His complexity is further revealed through his romantic entanglements, struggles with loyalty, and the moral dilemmas he faces, showcasing a character that is as multifaceted in his personal journey as he is in his magical endeavors.
  • Appearance: With his distinctive black hair, brown eyes, and preference for dark, stylish clothing, Nicholas's physical appearance complements his charismatic yet enigmatic persona. His look not only defines his character but also sets a visual standard for the warlock aesthetic within the series.

Role in the Story

  • Major Plot Points: Nicholas's narrative arc is rich with pivotal moments, from his initial introduction as a potential rival to becoming Sabrina's staunchest ally. His sacrificial act of becoming Lucifer's prison highlights his depth of character and dedication to what he believes is right.
  • Impact on the Narrative: Nicholas's actions and decisions significantly influence the series' direction, affecting Sabrina's path and the overarching battle against dark forces. His evolution from a carefree warlock to a character of profound depth and complexity adds a rich layer to the storytelling.

Cultural Impact

  • Fan Reception: Nicholas Scratch has become a beloved character among fans, celebrated for his complexity, charm, and the dynamic he brings to the series. His relationships, especially with Sabrina, have sparked extensive discussions, fan theories, and a dedicated following.
  • Thematic Significance: Nicholas embodies the themes of redemption, love, and the search for identity, mirroring broader cultural trends around personal growth and the nature of heroism. His character arc reflects a journey that resonates with audiences, making him a figure of both entertainment and introspection.

With a deeper understanding of Nicholas Scratch, you're equipped to bring his character to life, capturing the essence that has captivated fans worldwide.

Further Reading:


With detailed guidance on crafting Nicholas Scratch's iconic look, insights into embodying his essence, and creative ideas for group costumes, this guide has equipped you for a transformation that goes beyond mere attire. Our shared expertise and passion for costume creation have prepared you to capture Nicholas's charisma, complexity, and charm. Now, armed with knowledge and inspired by Nicholas Scratch's enigmatic spirit, you're ready to bring this beloved warlock to life. Embrace the adventure and let your transformation into Nicholas Scratch be as magical as the character himself!

Other "Chilling Adventures of Sabrina" Costume Ideas

Sabrina Spellman
Nicholas Scratch
4.5 2 votes
Rate This Guide
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments