Lizzie Borden Costume – Halloween 2026

Lizzie Borden Halloween Costume Items

Lizzie Borden Halloween costume infographic showing pink floral Victorian dress, brown satin sash, lace choker, pearl earrings, black ankle boots, blood splatter FX, and hatchet prop

Lizzie Borden Costume Items

Affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Lizzie Borden Monster Netflix Victorian

1 Floral Puff-Sleeve Victorian Dress (essential)This dress does most of the work. The soft pink floral print and puffed sleeves establish the polite, high-society daughter she was raised to be, which is exactly the image the blood splatter later breaks. Skip the floral print and go plain black, and the costume reads as generic Victorian mourning instead of her specifically. Get a size that lets you move your arms freely, the sleeves can pinch on a snug fit.
See on Amazon
2 Brown Satin Ribbon Waist SashTies at the waist to recreate the amber-brown sash from her reference look. It also gives the plain dress some visual structure.
See on Amazon
3 Lace Choker Necklace with Heart PendantA tight lace collar with a small heart pendant, the kind of modest jewelry a Victorian daughter would actually wear.
See on Amazon
4 Teardrop Pearl Drop EarringsUnderstated pearl drops finish the fine-jewelry look. Check your own jewelry box first, plain pearl earrings are common enough.
See on Amazon
5 Theatrical Blood Splatter Spray FX (essential)This is what turns a period dress into a true crime costume. Spray it across the hands, the dress front, and one side of the face, light coverage reads more unsettling than a dress soaked solid red. It can stain fabric permanently, so test it on an old dress or a thrifted piece, not one you plan to return.
See on Amazon
6 Black Victorian Lace-Up Ankle BootsPeriod-accurate footwear that most modern boots don’t replicate. If you already own plain black lace-up boots, those will pass at a glance.
See on Amazon
7 Antique Wooden-Handle Hatchet Prop (essential)The single object that identifies this costume from across a room. Without it, the pink dress and blood just reads as a vague murder victim, not Lizzie Borden specifically. Get one with an obviously fake blade, and check your venue’s policy on prop weapons before you carry it.
See on Amazon

How to Style the Lizzie Borden Halloween Costume

People clock the pink dress first, proper, floral, almost sweet, and that’s the point. The blood has to look like it happened to that dress, not like it was part of the outfit from the start, so keep it concentrated on the hands and one side of the body rather than sprayed evenly all over. Overdo the blood and the costume reads as a generic zombie instead of a specific 1892 crime scene. At a party, if you skip the hatchet entirely, most people will just see a nice vintage dress with some paint on it and miss the reference completely.

When Bridget Sullivan, the family’s maid, was upstairs and heard Lizzie calling, Lizzie’s actual words were “Maggie, come down! Come down quick; Father’s dead; somebody came in and killed him.” She used the name “Maggie” out of habit, it was what the Borden family called their maids regardless of their real names. That detail, calling for help while already knowing exactly what to say, is more character than any pose with the hatchet.

Reapply the blood spray before photos

Stage blood dries and dulls fast under indoor lighting, so it can look brownish and stale by the time anyone takes a picture. Keep the bottle with you and touch up the hands and face every hour or so if you want it to still read as fresh.

Decide your answer before someone asks “did she do it?”

This costume invites that question more than most, since the case was never definitively solved. Having a one-line answer ready, guilty, not guilty, or “the jury said no”, keeps the conversation moving instead of stalling out on a history lecture.

Lizzie Borden Group Halloween Costume Ideas

Duo Idea

Lizzie Borden & Ed Gein

Strong pairing for anyone who follows Ryan Murphy’s Monster anthology, since these are back-to-back seasons, Ed Gein in season three and Lizzie Borden in season four. Both are real historical killers whose crimes got flattened into folklore over time, a rural Wisconsin farmhouse next to a Victorian parlor. The visual contrast, her prim floral dress against his rougher, worn-in look, does a lot of the work without either person needing to explain the reference.

Lizzie Borden Ed Gein

Group Idea: Monster Anthology Killers

Lizzie Borden, Jeffrey Dahmer & The Menendez Brothers

Might work, but only for a crowd that watches this specific Netflix franchise closely. Dahmer, the Menendez brothers, and Lizzie Borden span three completely different eras and crime types, an 1892 axe case, 1990s brothers on trial, and a 1990s cannibal serial killer, so the only real thread connecting them is the show that adapted all three. It plays best as a themed group at a true-crime watch party, not a costume that reads on its own at a general Halloween party.

Lizzie Borden Jeffrey Dahmer The Menendez Brothers

Poster-style reference image of Lizzie Borden in her pink Victorian dress holding a hatchet for the Halloween costume

Lizzie Borden Halloween Costume DIY Tips

Building the Look

Most of this list is cheap or already in your closet. The dress and the blood spray are the two worth ordering ahead of time.

Dress: a floral Victorian-style dress is hard to thrift in the right silhouette, order this one.
Sash: any brown or amber ribbon works, doesn’t need to be satin specifically.
Choker and earrings: check your jewelry box before buying anything new.
Boots: plain black lace-up boots you already own will pass at a glance.
Blood spray: buy a real stage FX product, not craft paint, it dries wrong and can stain skin.
Hatchet: buy a prop one with an obviously fake blade, don’t try to make your own from a real tool.

Playing Lizzie at the Party

She’s polite and composed on the surface, that’s what made the crime so shocking to people who knew her.

Keep your tone calm and pleasant even while holding the hatchet, the mismatch is the whole joke.
If someone asks what happened, “somebody came in and killed him” works as a deadpan in-character line.
Skip a New England accent unless you can do it convincingly, a bad one undercuts the costume more than no accent at all.

Lizzie Borden Halloween Costume: FAQ

How do I dress like Lizzie Borden for Halloween 2026?

Start with the pink floral puff-sleeve Victorian dress, that period silhouette is the whole base of the look. Cinch the waist with a brown satin sash, add the lace choker and pearl drop earrings for the fine-jewelry finish, and lace up the black Victorian ankle boots. Then apply the blood splatter FX across the hands, dress front, and face, and carry the hatchet prop, those two pieces are what turn a Victorian outfit into Lizzie Borden specifically.

Is the Lizzie Borden costume still a good choice for Halloween 2026?

Yes, and 2026 is actually the best year to do it. Netflix’s Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, starring Ella Beatty, premiered September 17, 2026, putting her back in the cultural conversation after decades of the case being mostly known through the schoolyard rhyme. The pink dress and axe combo reads instantly to true crime fans, though it will mean less to anyone who has not seen the show or heard the rhyme.

What are Lizzie Borden’s most famous quotes?

When she called for the maid after finding her father’s body, she said: “Maggie, come down! Come down quick; Father’s dead; somebody came in and killed him.” When a police official called Abby her mother, she corrected him: “She was not my mother, sir. She was my stepmother; my mother died when I was a child.” And after her acquittal in 1893, she told reporters: “I am the happiest woman in the world.”

Who plays Lizzie Borden in the 2026 Netflix series?

Ella Beatty plays Lizzie Borden in Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, the fourth season of Ryan Murphy’s true crime anthology series on Netflix. The season also stars Vicky Krieps, Charlie Hunnam, Rebecca Hall, and Sarah Paulson.

Did Lizzie Borden actually kill her parents?

Nobody knows for certain. She was tried in 1893 for the axe murders of her father Andrew and stepmother Abby, and a jury acquitted her after a short deliberation. Many of her Fall River neighbors believed she was guilty anyway, and no one else was ever convicted, so the case has stayed officially unsolved for over 130 years.

How many times were Andrew and Abby Borden actually struck?

Abby was struck roughly 18 to 19 times and Andrew around 11 times, not the “forty whacks” and “forty-one” made famous by the playground rhyme. The rhyme was written years after the murders and inflated both numbers for effect.

When did Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story premiere?

It premiered September 17, 2026 on Netflix, with all 8 episodes released at once. Ian Brennan created this season, focusing on gender roles and class in Victorian Fall River.