Halloween Costume Guide
Annie January grew up in Des Moines, trained since childhood to be a superhero, and got everything she ever wanted when she joined The Seven. Then she found out what The Seven actually was. Played by Erin Moriarty across all five seasons of Amazon’s The Boys, Starlight is the show’s moral center, the one character who was genuinely trying to do the right thing from the start, and who spent five seasons discovering what that actually costs. She quit on live social media with 193 million followers watching. They included it in the recap.
Affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The yellow boots land first and carry the recognition load. Everything else layers around them. The costume should be clean and unwrinkled. Starlight’s look is neat rather than polished, the difference being that polished implies effort and Starlight’s presentation is genuinely effortless. The headband, necklace, and earrings add the personal touches that distinguish her from a generic superhero, and they read well in photos even when the costume itself is not in frame.
At the end of Season 3, standing in front of a camera with everything having gone wrong, Annie says: “And one more thing. I’m not Starlight anymore. My name is Annie January, and I f***ing quit.” She had been waiting to say it for a long time. There is no anger in it. Just a person who finally got to say the true thing out loud, on the record, to 193 million people. That is the character at the party: someone who is actually trying, who has thought about what she believes, and who is still standing at the end of it.
Test the boots before the party
Go-go boots are a specific kind of footwear that varies significantly in comfort across brands and fit. Some are easy to wear for four hours. Some are not. Put them on at home, walk around, confirm the calf fit is comfortable and the sole has enough support for an evening on your feet. Discovering they pinch or rub at the event is not a small problem when yellow boots are the costume’s most important item and leaving them behind is not an option.
Choose your Starlight era deliberately
Item 1 is who Annie became. Item 6 is who Vought tried to make her be. Both are recognizable to fans and both are accurate to different points in the character’s arc. The bodysuit from Season 1 is a conversation starter specifically because viewers know she hated it and pushed back against it. The standard costume is the version she chose for herself. Neither choice is wrong, but knowing which one you are wearing and why makes for a more interesting costume if someone asks.
Couples Idea
Excellent couple concept for The Boys fans. The central relationship of the entire series: a genuine hero and the guy who started out bugging her phone and ended up being the person she chose. The visual contrast is strong and immediately legible to anyone who knows the show. Hughie has no dedicated CostumeRealm guide, so that costume builds from scratch: jeans, a band t-shirt (his Pink t-shirt is the most specific reference from Season 1), casual shoes, general anxious energy.
Duo Idea
Excellent duo. Starlight and Maeve are the only two members of The Seven who consistently try to do the right thing, which makes them both targets and eventual allies. The visual contrast between Starlight’s bright white look and Maeve’s warrior aesthetic is strong. Both have CostumeRealm guides. Anyone who watches the show will understand exactly what this pairing means without any explanation from either of you.
Group Idea: The Boys Full Squad
Excellent group for a The Boys event. Seven characters from across both sides of the central conflict, all with CostumeRealm guides. Starlight is the most visually distinctive of the group in terms of color contrast, which makes her easy to spot in group photos. The full lineup covers heroes, villains, and the morally complicated people in between, which is the whole show in seven costumes.
Group Idea: Female Superheroes Who Don’t Need Saving
Strong group for a superhero-focused event. Seven female heroes from across Marvel, DC, and The Boys, all defined by being capable of handling whatever gets thrown at them. The thematic connection is clear and the visual variety is strong: white and yellow, red and gold, green, blue and gold, blue and red, black tactical gear, and red and gold. All seven have CostumeRealm guides. The group crosses multiple franchises, which broadens recognition across different crowd types at any event.
Seven items, but items 1 and 6 are alternatives. Pick one costume version, not both. The build is otherwise straightforward: costume, accessories, boots.
Annie is a genuine person, which in a world full of performers and manipulators is actually the most disorienting thing about her. She means what she says. That is the whole character.
Start with the Starlight costume (item 1) or the bodysuit version (item 6) depending on which era of the character you want. Add the yellow go-go boots, white headband, gold chain necklace, and hoop earrings. Use the blonde wig if your hair is not already light and wavy. The yellow boots are the detail that makes the look immediately specific to Starlight.
One of the strongest choices in The Boys lineup for 2026. Season 5 just concluded with Starlight’s arc fully resolved and her ending among the most satisfying in the series, meaning the character is at peak recognition and cultural goodwill. The costume is bright, immediately legible from a distance, and distinctive enough to land without explanation at any crowd that has seen the show.
Two lines define her. The first is what she says to anyone asking about joining The Seven: “Never meet your heroes.” It sounds like a cliche until you know why she says it. The second is from her Season 3 live social media resignation, delivered with complete calm after everything: “And one more thing. I’m not Starlight anymore. My name is Annie January, and I f***ing quit.” She had been waiting to say that sentence for a long time.
Erin Moriarty plays Starlight across all five seasons of The Boys. She is one of five actors to appear in every episode of the main series. Annie is the only character to be a member of both The Seven and The Boys, which required Moriarty to play the same person performing two very different versions of herself simultaneously for several seasons running.
Item 1 is the standard costume she wore for most of the series, the design she chose for herself after pushing back on Vought. Item 6 is the more revealing bodysuit Vought pressured her into wearing in Season 1, which she actively resisted and eventually got changed. The bodysuit is accurate to her earliest arc. The standard costume reflects who she became. Both are recognizable to fans, and the choice is a character statement.
The yellow boots are not optional. Without them the white costume could be several characters. The headband adds close-up accuracy and is worth including. The necklace and earrings reward people who know the character well but do not carry the recognition weight the boots do. If you are cutting anything, cut the jewelry last.
At the end of Season 3, Annie records a live social media post, names Homelander directly, tells the public the truth about Soldier Boy, and quits The Seven on camera with 193 million followers watching. The speech ends with her declaring she is not Starlight anymore, she is Annie January, and she quits. She then joins The Boys officially.